ESSAY: I Am Qualified, Why Not Me? Incident Analysis

Read Ch. 5, Incident 2, “I am Qualified, Why Not Me?”

Write a 700- to 1,400-word analysis, using your research, of the incident, “I am qualified, Why Not Me?” Include the following in preparing your response:

Discuss whether or not you believe that Bobby has a legitimate complaint. Does any organization, like Crystal Productions, have a responsibility to provide training and development opportunities to enhance promotion from within?
Explain the advantages and disadvantages of a promotion from within policy and whether such a policy would be appropriate for Crystal Productions.
Identify, if you were the head of HR, the first step in creating the policy, who should be involved in developing the policy, and what you would do in preparing for implementation.
Recommend the desired goals/outcomes of such a policy and the impact your new policy would have on staffing and performance management strategies.
Summarize what impact the changing workforce might have on your new policy.
Summarize a brief policy that addresses hiring from within.

INCIDENT 2 I Am Qualified, Why Not Me?
Five years ago, when Bobby Bret joined Crystal Productions as a junior accountant, he felt that he was on his way up. He had just graduated with a
B
+
average from college where he was well liked by his peers and by the faculty, and had been an officer in several student organizations. Bobby had shown a natural ability to get along with people as well as to get things done. He remembered what Roger Friedman, the controller at Crystal, had told him when he was hired, “I think you will do well here, Bobby. You’ve come highly recommended. You are the kind of guy that can expect to move right on up the ladder.”

Bobby felt that he had done a good job at Crystal, and everybody seemed to like him. In addition, his performance appraisals had been excellent. However, after five years he was still a junior accountant. He had applied for two senior accountant positions that had opened, but they were both filled by people hired from outside the firm. When the accounting supervisor’s job came open two years ago, Bobby had not applied. He was surprised when his new boss turned out to be a hotshot graduate of State University whose only experience was three years with a large accounting firm. Bobby had hoped that Ron Greene, a senior accountant he particularly respected, would get the job.

On the fifth anniversary of his employment at Crystal, Bobby decided it was time to do something. He made an appointment with the controller. At that meeting, Bobby explained to Mr. Friedman that he had worked hard to obtain a promotion and shared his frustration about having been in the same job for so long. “Well,” said Mr. Friedman, “you don’t think that you were all that much better qualified than the people that we have hired, do you?” “No,” said Bobby, “but I think I could have handled the senior accountant job. Of course, the people you have hired are doing a great job too.” The controller responded, “We just look at the qualifications of all the applicants for each job, and considering everything, try to make a reasonable decision.”

ANSWER

I am qualified, why not me? Incident Analysis

            Crystal Productions hired Bobby to be their junior consultant. Upon hiring, Roger Friedman, Crystal Productions’ controller believed he could excel in the company since he was the kind of person who was expected to quickly “move right up the ladder.” Bobby, despite the recognition and belief bestowed on him, went ahead to apply for other senior positions. These positions were hired by people from outside the organization, and after an outsider was hired to occupy the available accounting supervisor position, Bobby spoke with Roger Friedman about it. In turn, Roger Friedman affirmed that the company simply “look at the qualifications of every applicant” before making a…

Bobby’s Complaint

           Bobby’s complaint to Roger Friedman originates from the conversation they heard whereby he told him it was possible to move up the ladder. As a result, Bobby was influenced following the conversation since he believed the company pays a lot of focus on internal, rather than external promotions. Bobby was frustrated although there was no promise of any promotion in the future, nor was he promised that promotions would come from within the company. In turn, since the company hires based primarily on individual qualifications, the hired ones would be more qualified than Bobby for the vacant position, thus his complaint to Roger Friedman was unwarranted. In this case, it is evident Crystal Productions may be limiting their employees’ potential to “move up the ladder” since they do not provide training and development opportunities, including few internal promotions. According to Bayo-Moriones and Ortin-Angel (2006), there is a connection …

Advantages and Disadvantages of Internal Promotions

           Internal recruitment refers to the process of making open positions available to employees within the organization before filling the remaining positions outside the organization. Landeta et al. (2009) observe the tools used to facilitate internal recruitment, which includes job postings, HR databases, job bidding, and employee referrals. Job opportunities, in the past, were posted in the company’s break room; today, organizations utilize various web-based applications and company intranet to post available positions, as well as search for qualified candidates.            One of the advantages is that the prioritization of internal employees…