MSN565 Signature Assignment

MSN565 Signature Assignment Rubric ASL v1 Course: Nursing Leadership And Health

MSN565 Signature Assignment Rubric ASL v1 Course: Nursing Leadership And Health Policy – CFG – 08-31-21 – Sect8

Criteria Does Not Meet Expectations

Approaches Expectation

Meets Expectations

Exceeds Expectations

Criterion Score

Policy

Challenge

Statement

Weight: 30%

/ 810 points

Default=0

Range=0-62

Policy

challenge/proble

m statement is

unclear, weak or

missing. The

presentation

does not

describe key

stakeholders, the

agenda, or the

interview with

the nurse

leader/nursing

association/orga

nization.

63 points

Default=63

Range=63-71

Basic

introduction of

policy

challenge/proble

m. States

problem but

lacks support.

The challenge

statement is

somewhat clear

and arguable, but

briefly mentions

the key

stakeholders, and

does not discuss

each

stakeholder’s

role and the

agenda

adequately.

Briefly discusses

the interview

with the nurse

leader/nursing

association/orga

nization.

72 points

Default=72

Range=72-80

Proficiently

makes a policy

challenge/proble

m statement that

is relevant. The

challenge

statement is a

clear and

arguable

statement of

position.

Mentions the key

stakeholders and

their roles and

the agenda.

Describes the

interview with

the nurse

leader/nursing

association/orga

nization.

81 points

Default=81

Range=81-90

Total D2L Point

Value=90

Exceptional

policy

challenge/proble

m statement that

grabs interest of

reader and states

topic, is

exceptionally

clear, arguable,

well-developed,

and a definitive

statement.

Exceptionally

defines the key

stakeholders and

their roles and

the agenda. The

interview with

the nurse

leader/nursing

association/orga

nization leaves

the reader with a

clear

understanding of

the situation.

Criteria Does Not Meet Expectations

Approaches Expectation

Meets Expectations

Exceeds Expectations

Criterion Score

Quality of

Information or

Evidence

Weight: 25%

/ 680 points

Default=0

Range=0-52

Information does

not relate to the

main topic.

Presentation is

not researched in

sufficient detail

and from a

variety of

sources. All

necessary

content is not

included. Does

not list the

different

strategies that

the organization

plans to or has

already used to

inform/lobby

legislators. Does

not describe two

or three

strategies used

to inform

legislators. Does

not list and

describe any

non-legislative

strategies that

were used or

plan to be used

to support the

initiative.

53 points

Default=53

Range=53-59

Information

relates to the

main topic. But

the presentation

is missing

sufficient detail

from a variety of

sources; key

components of

content may be

missing. The

presentation is

missing the

different

strategies that

the

organization/indi

vidual plans to or

has already used

to inform/lobby

legislators. A

description of

any non-

legislative

strategies that

were used or

plan to be used

may be missing.

60 points

Default=60

Range=60-67

Information

relates to the

main topic. The

presentation is

researched in

sufficient detail

and from a

variety of

sources. All

necessary

content is

included. Lists

the different

strategies that

the organization

plans to or has

already used to

inform/lobby

legislators.

Describes two or

three strategies

used to inform

legislators. Lists

and describes

any non-

legislative

strategies that

were used or

plan to be used

to support the

initiative.

68 points

Default=68

Range=68-75

Total D2L point

Value=75

Presentation is

exceptionally

researched,

extremely

detailed, and

accurate.

Information

clearly relates to

the challenge

statement.

Appropriate

content is

covered in depth

without being

redundant. Lists

and describes in

detail at least

four different

legislative and

non-legislative

strategies that

the organization

plans to or has

already used to

inform/lobby

legislators.

Criteria Does Not Meet Expectations

Approaches Expectation

Meets Expectations

Exceeds Expectations

Criterion Score

Support of

Analysis

Weight: 25%

/ 68

Quality of

Written/Oral

Communicatio

n Weight: 10%

/ 28

0 points

Default=0

Range=0-52

Limited or no

connections

made between

evidence. Lacks

analysis. Does

not describe

where this policy

challenge is in

the legislative

process and its

implications for

the future.

53 points

Default=53

Range=53-59

Some

connections have

been made

between

evidence and

analysis. Minimal

analysis is

evident, but does

not provide

detailed support

for the challenge

statement.

Briefly describes

where this policy

challenge is in

the legislative

process and its

implications for

the future.

60 points

Default=60

Range=60-67

Consistent

connections

made between

evidence and the

analysis which

sufficiently

supports the

challenge

statement

Describes where

this policy

challenge is in

the legislative

process.

Implications for

the future are

logical and

insightful.

68 points

Default=68

Range=68-75

Total D2L point

Value=75

Exceptionally

critical, relevant,

and consistent

connections

made between

evidence and

analysis.

Excellent analysis

is evident of

describing where

this policy

challenge is in

the legislative

process and its

implications for

the future.

0 points

Default=0

Range=0-20

Style and voice

inappropriate or

do not address

given audience,

purpose, etc.

Word choice is

excessively

redundant,

clichéd, and

unspecific.

Presentation is

not recorded.

Inconsistent

grammar,

spelling,

punctuation, and

21 points

Default=21

Range=21-23

Style and voice

are somewhat

appropriate to

the given

audience and

purpose. Word

choice is often

unspecific,

generic,

redundant, and

clichéd.

Presentation is

recorded and is

3-5 minutes.

Repetitive

mechanical

24 points

Default=24

Range=24-27

Style and voice

are appropriate

to the given

audience and

purpose. Word

choice is specific

and purposeful,

and somewhat

varied

throughout.

Presentation is

recorded 5-10

minutes. Minimal

mechanical or

typographical

errors are

28 points

Default=28

Range=28-30

Total D2L Point

Value=30

Style and voice

are not only

appropriate to

the given

audience and

purpose, but also

show originality

and creativity.

Presentation is

recorded 5-10

minutes. Free of

mechanical and

typographical

errors. A variety

Criteria Does Not Meet Expectations

Approaches Expectation

Meets Expectations

Exceeds Expectations

Criterion Score paragraphing.

Delivery

techniques

(posture,

gestures, eye

contact, vocals)

detract from

understandability

of presentation

and speaker

appears nervous

and

uncomfortable.

APA format is

not evident in

the references

slide.

errors distract

the reader.

Information is

repeated and

somewhat

disorganized;

delivery

techniques make

speaker appear

tentative and

unsure. There are

missing APA

elements or

some are

incorrectly

formatted

throughout the

presentation.

present, but are

not overly

distracting to the

reader. Delivery

techniques make

speaker appear

comfortable.

Mostly accurate

APA formatting

of the references

slide is evident.

of sentence

structures and

effective figures

of speech are

used. Writer is

clearly in

command of

standard,

written,

academic

English. Delivery

techniques make

speaker appear

confident and

polished;

language/word

choices are

imaginative,

memorable, and

compelling to

support the

effectiveness of

the presentation.

Completely

accurate APA

formatting of the

references slide

is evident.

Total / 272

Criteria Does Not Meet Expectations

Approaches Expectation

Meets Expectations

Exceeds Expectations

Criterion Score

Use of

Multimedia,

Graphics,

Diagrams,

and/or

Illustrations

Weight: 5%

/ 13.5

Presentation

Organization

Weight: 5%

/ 13.5

0 points

Default=0

Range=0-9.5

Does not include

required

multimedia,

graphics,

diagrams, and/or

illustrations or

they are

irrelevant to

topic or detract

from slide

content or

presentation as a

whole.

10.5 points

Default=10.5

Range=10.5-11

Required

multimedia,

graphics,

diagrams, and/or

illustrations are

generally

relevant but

some may not

appropriately

support the slide

content.

12 points

Default=12

Range=12-12.5

Required

multimedia,

graphics,

diagrams, and/or

illustrations are

highly relevant

and acceptably

support the slide

content; sized

and positioned

appropriately.

13.5 points

Default=13.5

Range=13.5-15

Total D2L Point

Value=15

Required

multimedia,

graphics,

diagrams, and/or

illustrations add

clarity and

sophistication to

the presentation

content; they

improve the

effectiveness of

the presentation.

0 points

Default=0

Range=0-9.5

Organization

pattern (specific

introduction/con

clusion,

sequenced

material within

the body, and

transitions) is not

observable

within the

presentation.

10.5 points

Default=10.5

Range=10.5-11

Organization

pattern is

intermittently

observable

within the

presentation

12 points

Default=12

Range=12-12.5

Organization

pattern is clear

and observable

within the

presentation.

13.5 points

Default=13.5

Range=13.5-15

Total D2L Point

Value=15

Organization

pattern is skillful

and permits a

cohesiveness in

the presentation.

Overall Score

Does Not Meet

Expectations 0 points minimum

Approaches

Expectation 211 points minimum

Meets

Expectations 240 points

minimum

Exceeds

Expectations 272 points minimum